Brooklyn research brief ·
What Brooklyn’s condo tax records can tell us
NYC’s condo tax abatement is generally for owners who live in their units. We looked for units where the owner might qualify, using the address where the City sends the tax bill as a clue.
- Exact match, absent from Aug. 2026 credit extract
- 687
- Exact match, listed in that extract
- 99
- Different street address or apartment
- 1,542
- Incomplete or conflicting address
- 72
An exact match means the street address and apartment on the billing record agree with the assessment roll after standardizing their format.
What the model found
The study screened 54,166 Brooklyn residential Class 2 condo tax lots. Of those, 15,512 passed the bulk filters and had a positive modeled benefit. The address sample came from this smaller group.
$8.19 million
Modeled annual gross tax reduction in Brooklyn, assuming every exact match absent from the August 2026 credit extract qualifies and receives the benefit. The model uses FY2026 tax figures, before fees and any compliance costs.
The adjusted sampling interval is $7.27–$9.11 million. It measures variation from drawing a sample. Errors in the address rule, eligibility, assessment inputs and later changes can move the result beyond that interval.
About 74% of the modeled dollars came from developments flagged by our screen for a possible prevailing-wage affidavit requirement. The screen used development size and average assessed value. It did not verify wages, affidavits or the City’s determination for any development. Removing every flagged development would bring the modeled total to $2.10 million. That scenario illustrates how much of the result depends on that group.
About $5.99 million (73%) came from developments without a positive condo abatement row in the FY2026 extract. The other $2.20 million (27%) came from developments with a positive record. Both groups can include developments flagged for the prevailing-wage requirement.
We observed a billing and credit-record pattern. The records establish neither who lives in these units nor what the City owes. The study did not establish a refund, an approved application or a credit posted as a result of Atlas’s work.
How we counted
The study covers Brooklyn Class 2 residential condo lots in building classes R1, R2, R3, R4 and R6. Co-ops, condops, rental-condo blocks, commercial condos and Class 1 condos are outside its scope.
-
Screen the FY2026 roll
We counted each tax lot once and grouped lots by condo development. A development can span multiple buildings. We screened out lots with a condo abatement record, apparent entity or ambiguous ownership, more than three units under the same recorded owner name within a development, and potentially incompatible or unclear tax benefits. Some of these exclusions can omit legally eligible cases.
-
Check the billing address
We drew 2,400 lots across 1,045 developments using a fixed random ordering of the 15,512 candidates, without replacement. We obtained each selected page on November 4, 2026. Exact address and apartment matches counted toward the estimate. Other addresses and unresolved cases counted as zero. A matching address can be used by someone who lives elsewhere, and an owner who lives in the unit may have a bill sent to an agent or another address.
-
Estimate the benefit and check a newer extract
We applied the FY2026 Class 2 rate of 12.439% to billed assessed value less billed exemptions, subtracted modeled compatible credits and applied the development’s abatement tier of 17.5% to 28.1%. Where the City’s development value or tier was unavailable, we used the mean assessed value of its residential lots to model the tier.
Using only the FY2026 credit file, the model gives $9.64 million (adjusted sampling interval $8.66–$10.62 million). We then removed 99 sample matches that appear in the FY2027 Q2 extract dated August 15, 2026. The resulting $8.19 million retains the FY2026 assessments, tax rate and screens. An absence in that quarter’s file leaves open credits recorded in other quarters or later adjustments.
Sampling formula and address scenarios
Let N be the candidate count, n the sample count and s the sample standard deviation. We multiplied the mean modeled dollars per sampled lot (including zeroes) by N. The standard error is N × s × √((1 − n/N)/n). The approximate t interval applies a Bonferroni correction across 24 checks, one per 100 lots, for a nominal 95% level across those checks. The Q2-adjusted interval has an 11.2% relative half-width at 2,400 lots, above the study’s 10% precision target.
| Scenario | Annual model |
|---|---|
| Remove 10% of exact-match dollars, with no added matches | $7.37 million |
| Remove 25% of exact-match dollars, with no added matches | $6.14 million |
| Keep all exact-match dollars and assume every unresolved case absent from Q2 qualifies | $9.26 million |
The last illustration leaves all differently addressed lots at zero. None of these scenarios measures actual occupancy or brackets what the City might award.
Data and sources
The aggregate file includes the counts and sample totals needed to recalculate both estimates and the adjusted sampling intervals.
Download aggregate data (CSV)- NYC Department of Finance final assessment roll. FY2026, May 13, 2025 extract. Assessment archives · Class 2–4 bulk ZIP · File layout (XLSX)
- NYC Open Data, abatement and exemption detail. Brooklyn FY2026 final exemptions (May 13, 2025), FY2026 Q4 abatements (February 20, 2026) and FY2027 Q2 condo abatements (August 15, 2026). We downloaded the files on November 4, 2026. Exemption detail · Abatement detail · Brooklyn FY2026 Q4 (CSV) · Brooklyn FY2027 Q2 condo abatements (CSV)
- Condo map and billing records. Map downloaded and FY2026 portal records retrieved November 4, 2026. Digital Tax Map condominiums · What the billing address means
- Program rules and rates. Owners certify their primary residence to the board or its agent. The authorized representative files with the City. Ownership, purchase timing and prevailing-wage rules can affect eligibility. NYC Department of Finance program guidance · NYC property tax rates
The same FY2026 roll classifications cover 227,157 residential condo tax lots across the five boroughs. We estimated abatement amounts for Brooklyn only.
About this project
Joel Witten led this independent study and is developing Abatement Atlas as a potential paid service to help Brooklyn condo boards with routine abatement renewals. The research also covers developments that may need to apply for the first time. The proposed pilot serves condos that already receive the benefit. It is gathering feedback, with no paid engagements open. The pilot’s sample board packet uses fictional records and outcomes. Proposed renewal pilot